The Ogden Memorial Presbyterian Church [website] replaced the Village Church of Chatham (below) in 1904. Initially, this land belonged to the Episcopals, but the Presbyterians gave ‘em their old chapel back on the Village Church property, so everyone was even.
Reference:
Cunningham, J.T. (1997). Images of America: Chatham. Arcadia Publishing: Dover, NH. ISBN 0738545619.
New Providence Daily Photo 