Central Presbyterian Church in Summit (on the corner of Maple Street and Morris Avenue; click here for a Google Street View) was organized in 1870, and this big stone church was constructed in 1906. So until this big stone thing was built, the congregation hung out in the wooden church featured below.
Central Presbyterian Church, 1874ish
After they had a nice big stone church to worship in, they continued using this old church for Sunday school until 1924.
Aaaaaaand then they knocked it down in the late 1920s.
So it is no longer a feature of the area.
P.S. The dates may be off, so here’s a photo of the modern stone (concrete?) cornerstone so you can draw your own conclusions.
Vintage photo and information from:
The Summit Historical Society. (1978). Glimpses into Summit’s past: A selection of photographs and texts tracing the city’s growth. Benway, Maxwell & Smith: Chatham, NJ.
New Providence Daily Photo 